 |  | A Papa John's in Ottawa, IL. (October, 2004/April, 2025) |
 | A Shell/Papa John's in Peru, IL. (October, 2004) |
 | A Subway/Papa Johns in Bloomington, IL. (February, 2006) |
 | A Papa Johns in Columbia, MO. (February, 2010) |
 | A Big Lots/Papa Johns in Bradley, IL. (March, 2010) |
 | A Fashion Bug/Papa John's in East Peoria, IL. (May, 2012) |
 | A Blockbuster/Papa John's in Montgomery, IL. (January, 2013) |
 | A Papa John's in South Holland, IL. (August, 2013) |
 | A Papa John's in Yorkville, IL. (November, 2013) |
 | A Papa John's in Moline, IL. (December, 2013) |
 | A Papa Johns in Hammond, IN. (June, 2014) |
 | A Papa Johns in Chicago, IL. (June, 2014) |
 |  | A Papa Johns in Washington, IL. (July, 2014/August, 2024) |
 | A Papa Johns in Davenport, IA. (July, 2014) |
 | A Papa Johns/Penn Station in St. Ann, MO. (August, 2014) |
 | A Papa Johns in Quincy, IL. (August, 2014) |
 | A Papa Johns in Macomb, IL. (August, 2014) |
 | A Papa John's in Belleville, IL. (September, 2014) |
 | A Papa John's in Elkhart, IN. (October, 2014) |
 |  | A Papa Johns in DeKalb, IL. (July, 2015/September, 2024) |
 | A Papa Johns in Niles, IL. (July, 2015) |
 | A Papa Johns in Madison, WI. (July, 2015) |
 | A Papa Johns in Normal, IL. (February, 2016) |
 | A Papa Johns/Dollar Tree in Lafayette, IN. (February, 2016) |
 | A Papa Johns Lafayette, IN. (September, 2016) |
 | A Papa Johns in Champaign, IL. (July, 2016) |
 | A Starbuck's/Papa Johns in Lisle, IL. (October, 2016) |
 |  | A Papa Johns in Michigan City, IN. (February, 2017/March, 2024) |
 |  | A Papa Johns in Munster, IN. (February, 2017/June, 2021) |
 | A Papa Johns in Merrillville, IN. (February, 2017) |
 | A Papa John's/Dollar General in Crown Point, IN. (February, 2017) |
 | A Papa John's in Canton, IL. (April, 2017) |
 | A Papa John's in South Bend, IN. (June, 2017) |
 | A Papa John's in Logansport, IN. (June, 2017) |
 | A Papa Johns in Peru, IN. (June, 2017) |
 | A Papa Johns in Granite City, IL. (July, 2017) |
 | A Papa Johns in Elkhart, IN. (September, 2017) |
 | A Papa Johns/Payless Shoe Source in Portage, MI. (September, 2017) |
 | A Papa Johns in Belleville, IL. (August, 2018) |
 | A Papa John's in O'Fallon, IL. (August, 2018) |
 | A Family Dollar/Papa John's in Paducah, KY. (August, 2018) |
 | A Papa John's in Paducha, KY. (August, 2018) |
 | A Papa John's/Sears Hometown store in Madisonville, KY. (August, 2018) |
 | A Papa John's in Sullivan, IN. (August, 2018) |
 | A Papa John's in Chesterton, IN. (August, 2018) |
 | A Papa Johns in Peoria, IL. (May, 2019) |
 | A Papa Johns/Penn Station in Maryland Heights, MO. (June, 2019) |
 | A Papa Johns in North Olmsted, OH. (July, 2019) |
 | A Papa Johns in Pittsburgh, PA. (July, 2019) |
 | A Pape Johns in Bridgeport, OH. (July, 2019) |
 | A Papa Johns in Indianapolis, IN. (July, 2019) |
 | A Papa Johns in Shelbyville, IN. (July, 2019) |
 | A Papa Johns in Frankfort, IL. (August, 2019) |
 | A Papa Johns in West Dunee, IL. (September, 2019) |
 | A Papa Johns in Crest Hill, IL (September, 2019) |
 | A Subway/Papa Johns/Little Ceaser's in Plymouth, IN. (January, 2020) |
 | A Dollar Tree/Papa John's in Kalamazoo, MI. (August, 2020) |
 | A Papa Johns in South Bend, IN (August, 2020) |
 | A Pizza John's in Galesburg, IL. (September, 2020) |
 | A Domino's/Papa John's in Holland, MI. (March, 2021) |
 | A Papa John's in Burbank, IL. (April, 2021) |
 | A Papa John's in Nicholasville, KY. (March, 2022) |
 | A Papa Johns in Middlesboro, KY. (March, 2022) |
 | A Papa Johns in Barbourville, KY. (March, 2022) |
 | A Papa John's in Louisville, KY. (April, 2022) |
 | A Papa John's in St. Louis, MO. (June, 2022) |
 | A Papa John's in Rolla, MO. (June, 2022) |
 | A Papa John's in Oakville, MO. (June, 2022) |
 | A Papa John's/Wing Stop in Fenton, MO. (June, 2022) |
 | A Papa John's in Arnold, MO. (June, 2022) |
 | A Papa John's/Smootie King in St. Louis, MO. (June, 2022) |
 | A Papa John's in Imperial, MO. (June, 2022) |
 | A Papa John's in Fond du Lac, WI. (September, 2022) |
 | An Advanced Auto Parts/Papa Johns in Crawfordsville, IN. (November, 2022) |
 | A Papa John's in St. Charles, MO. (January, 2023) |
 | A Papa John's in Valley Park, MO. (May, 2023) |
 | A Papa John's/Chipotle in Chesterfield, MO. (May, 2023) |
 | A Papa John's in Glen Carbon, IL. (June, 2023) |
 | A Papa John's in Traverse City, MI. (July, 2023) |
 | A Northlands/Papa John's in Kingsley, MI. (July, 2023) |
 | A Papa John's in Cadillac, MI. (July, 2023) |
 | A Papa John's in Springfield, IL. (August, 2023) |
 | A Papa John's in Evanston, IL. (March, 2024) |
 | A Papa John's in Grayslake, IL. (March, 2024) |
 | A Dickey's/Papa Johns in Schererville, IN. (March, 2024) |
 | A Papa Johns in Springfield, IL. (July, 2024) |
 | A Papa Johns in Brazil, IN. (July, 2024) |
 | A Papa Johns in Brazil, IN. (July, 2024) |
 | A Papa Johns in Jacksonville, IL. (July, 2024) |
 | A Papa Johns in Marion, IA. (September, 2024) |
 | A Papa Johns in Stevens Point, WI. (October, 2024) |
 | A Papa John's/Jimmy John's in Danville, IL. (November, 2024) |
 | A Papa John's in Wentzville, MO. (December, 2024) |
 | A Papa John's in Effingham, IL. (December, 2024) |
 | A Papa Johns in Mattoon, IL. (December, 2024) |
 | A Papa Johns in Beaver Falls, PA. (April, 2025) |
 | A Papa Johns in Weirton, WV. (April, 2025) |
 | A Papa Johns in Selinsgrove, PA. (April, 2025) |
 | A Papa Johns in Reading, PA. (April, 2025) |
 | A Papa John's/Rita's in Warminster, PA. (April, 2025) |
 | A Papa Johns in Maple Shade, NJ. (April, 2025) |
 | A Papa John's in Columbus, OH. (April, 2025) |
 | A Papa John's in Naperville, IL. (June, 2025) |
 | A Papa John's/Tropical Smoothie Cafe in Saginaw, MI. (August, 2025) |
 | A Papa John's in Springfield, IL. (September, 2025) |
 | A Papa John's in Rantoul, IL. (May, 2026) |
 | A Papa John's in Lincoln, IL. (May, 2026) |
 | A BP/Papa John's in West Liberty, IA. (May, 2026) |
 | A Papa John's/Dollar Tree in Taylorville, IL. (May, 2026) |